RogerBK's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Initiate]

Nice...

I really liked the effects, I think you made a great job wih this song, it's pretty cool, and the beat is very catchy, but I have one complain, the voices aren't so good to the song's context, I think it breaked the dark and creepy atmosphere of the song, but the other parts of the song were great, you used a lot of effects that helped the song in the final grade, it's always good to variate using more beats and sound effects...

The song got a bit too repetitive, but I thinkthe beat was very pleasant, so, it wasn't a bad thing to hear, there are lots and lots of annoying repetitive songs, this one's different... Also, the break was well done, you chosed the right parts to break the sound, the effects were simply awesome, nice variations and nice building...

The song's lenght was pretty cool, I think you passed your message, I didn't see the time passing, you really hypnotized me, it's great to listen to something interesting, this one was great, I loved the sound effects and the variations, the only bad thing was that voice in te beginning, thi really messed with the intro...

I see you have potential, you made a great song with a great lenght, I really wanna listen more from you, keep it up with the awesome work!! ;)

(Review Request Club)
Roger

DJ-Chilvan responds:

Thanks a lot man! Yea, its funny, cuz this song was just me experimenting with Ableton, but I've been making music forever so I just used that knowledge for this song.
I'm going to release a shorter version of this song, and it's not going to have any vocals. I will release it by the end of May.
Eyy, if you want to hear more from me, just add me to my favorite artists list. I'm going to release a couple songs sometime this week. For the meantime, some songs of mine I think you'll enjoy are "Lost Entity (Dance Remix)", "Euphoria," and "Dead Winter (Trance Remix)" to name a few. Don't worry man, making music is my hobby. You will be hearing more from me until the day I die lol.
Thanks!

[Nature Is The Law (WIP)]

Ramones Lyrics...

I liked the song, I think it's pretty cool and it remembers me of Nirvana, I don't know why, but it seems very grunge, just as like them. You must be wondering why I wrote ''Ramones Lyrics'', here's the explainment: The song has only 3 phrases, and Ramones have 3 chords, but they're awesomely well made...

The first verse was great, the guitar fitted so well to the voice, the drums were great too, since it gave life to the voice, but I felt that something is missing, a guitar would be very nice in the break, a little solo, maybe... It would make the song way better, I'm not saying that the song is bad, but it can be imroved...

Also, I think that the end gets too repetitive, there are so much ''(ah ah) Nature is the Law Now'', I think you could be more creative, but the song is super cool in this way... I just want to say that you have a great potential, keep it up, man.

(Review Request Club)
Roger
;)

[Stargenx - Spring Fling]

Nice song!

It was a pretty good song, Stargenx, pretty animated ad happy, I love this kind of songs, it always make me feel better, but this one was more than good, it had a perfect timing and a perfect melody, you did the right things, and all of them were awesome...

The intro remembered me of Thriller, from Michael Jackson, and then the melody appeared and gave a nice athmosphere to the rest of the song, since all the instruments were working well together, the drums made a great effect and a nice base and the synt had a nice melody, they made a great combination together, I simply loved it!!

I think that the little break was cool, it was nice to listen to a new melody afer a little break, this strategy always works, since the listeners pay more attention after a song break, and it gave a better athmosphere to the song...

I have nothing bad to say, just want to hear more from you, and say that you have to keep it up, since your work is awesome!!

(Review Request Club)
Roger

Stargenx responds:

Thanks, Roger! The intro is the work of not knowing how to start it out. This song was created when I was messing around with a pad in Logic and increased the cut. It sounded happy so I finished the song. XD
Thanks for the review!

[SN | Beautiful Arrhythmia | SN]

Cool...

I loved the piano, it's a perfect instrument, huh?? It gave a base to the song, what was great, since the synts gave the life to the song, also, the faster part was awesome, it had nice effects and an awesome atmosphere, I simply loved it...

The slower part was cool, too, since it prepared us to hear the faster part, what was awesome, because the song didn't have only faster and louder parts, there are people that like slower songs, and you made a nice mix of fast and slow songs... I liked this idea, man, it's great.

I can't say more things, I liked the song, but I think thare's something missing, you can add more things, since the song is pretty short, but, this is up to you, man... Keep it up w/ the awesome work, you have a great potential, and I wanna hear more from you...

(Review Request Club)
Roger

SessileNomad responds:

im not gonna add more, im pleased with this one the way it is

im glad you like it though, i worked a long time on this one

[New Qualification V2.0]

Nice

I liked how you builded the song, it was pretty cool, but I felt that something was missing, you could add more melodies, since the song was very quiet, but I loved the louder parts, it really broke the quiet and dark parts, it was a pretty nice thing, man, you made the right choice.

The drums beat was great, it has the right timing and the right beats, it wasn't loud, but it wasn't quiet, so, it gave me a great feeling when I heard this song. I think it gave this because the song have a spacial atmosphere, what is awesome...

The voices in the back were great, too, it was very frightening, but nothing too scary, it fitted perfectly with the drums and its rhythm, it was a great chemical, man, I liked it so much...

You have potential dude, I wanna hear more from you, keep it up with the good work man...

(Review Request Club)
Roger

[I have a potion]

Cool beat

I personally liked it, I love retro video game songs, such as the classical one from Mario (I LOVE it!). This was pretty good, it has nice sound effects, what only gives more personality to the song... I can't think in a game for this song, but I'm sure it could be a very good game... Just as like the frontpaged ones...

The song's variety was awesome, very random and cool, I love songs ike this one, they're very animated and happy, it gave me a nice feeling and a nice athmosphere in my room...

I believe you're one of the bests song makers from NG, Calamaistr, you have the most beautiful piano songs I ever heard, and this wasn't different... I just think you should add more things to the song and take some repetitive things off, then, the song will be great... Keep it up, man!

(Review Request Club)
Roger

Calamaistr responds:

I dont think theres still room in this track to add things, besides it would probably distract from the detail already present, like.. did you notice how the analog bips seem to flip like a rotating platform, if you would visualise what you hear.. at least thats what i see when i listen to this work of mine.

Its actually a very graphic track even though it is extremely minimalistic.

When the melody goes nuts is pretty much what i wanted to be the effect of drinking the potion, after wich ofcourse you'd want another potions.

So now you know why you kept buying em in games. ;>

Thanks, and greets Cal.

[[SxHx] Prfkt.Tempo]

Nice

I really liked this song, man, you really made a great song, the beats are awesome, they're very syncronized, and the voice is really awesome with that main beat, and the drums are great, too, I really think it's a great song...

The voice is great, man, t really fitted with the beat and the drums were so cool in the backbeat, since it's the base of the song, it really made a great mix together, you made a great job here, man, I really liked this one.

The synt. beat was awesome, you really made a great riff, it really remembers me of a Rammstein song, called Du Hast, it's pretty nice, and the synt have the same beat and rhythm of the guitars... I really loved it, awesome!

The song was very simple, but it's complex at the same time, I think you made a great song here, you have potential, keep it up!!

(Review Request Club)
Roger

[It's a Fuckin Loop!?]

...

It's kind of funny, man, I liked it, the beat is pretty cool, but, it's a loop, so, I can't say so much about it, I just think it'd be nice if you make the long version, I just think you could change more things, the sound is too annoying, you can change the beat, it would be very nice if you turned off the sound and made a drums beat louder than the back beat, it'd give a nice impression...

It remembered me of the Power Puff Girls intro song, it has a nice little beat, but I just think you can make a lot of changes in it before you post the full version.
But, anyways, I really think that this would result in a nice song, just make the right decisions... Keep it up GST!

Dj-GST responds:

Thanks man.

Yeah I'll definitely be making a longer version, and I'll totally turn those drums up, and get rid of those annoying bells :)

Powerpuff Girls? lol, I haven't watched that show in ages.

Later man.

[Tetris (A->N Remix)]

Great

Man, I really like this Tetris theme, I think it's one of the best Video Game songs, after Mario's and Zelda's this is the greatest one... And you made a nice remix, the beat is very technologic, you changed a lot the song, but it's still good to listen, I really liked it, another great song from you...

The drums beats were awesome, it really fitted to the song, and the breaks were good too, since it gave more personality to the song, and I think that personality is essencial to the song, since you put your own style in it... This song is a great song, as your other songs Nirvana, keep it up, man... I love your work.

(Review Request Club)
Roger

ApproachingNirvana responds:

Thanks for the review! :D

[Fond of Fortresses]

...

The song was very nice, but there were a lot of annoying sounds in the song, like the kind of bell, that hurted my ears, it wasn't loud, it had an unpleasant sound, just that.

I liked a lot of other sounds in the song, the back bass was very cool, it gave a nice sound to the song, also, the drums were pretty cool, since they gave life to the song, I think that was a very good addiction, it made an awesome sound at the final result...

I liked the song, it was pretty well executed, but it needs a lot of improvements, you have potential, but you can do a better job, man, anyways, keep it up, always trying to make a better work...

(Review Request Club)
Roger

svinepels responds:

What bell? You say the song needs a lot of improvements, but the only thing you mention is the bell that hurted your ears. Anyways, thanks for the review!